Managing Director/Underwriting Lead MGA


Chicago
Permanent
Negotiable
Insurance and Actuarial Science
PR/575079_1769479439
Managing Director/Underwriting Lead MGA

Senior Specialty Underwriting Leadership Opportunity (MGA Platform)

We are partnered with a well‑capitalized specialty MGA platform seeking experienced specialty underwriting leaders to build and grow underwriting portfolios and develop new specialty products within the U.S. market.

This opportunity is suited to professionals who have progressed beyond a traditional underwriting seat and are ready to own a specialty business, shape underwriting strategy, and operate with long‑term commercial and equity alignment. The scope may include one or more related specialty lines, rather than a single defined program.


The Role

  • Lead the development and growth of a specialty underwriting portfolio
  • Drive the launch of new specialty products or underwriting capabilities in the U.S.
  • Set underwriting appetite, pricing discipline, and portfolio strategy
  • Build and scale a sustainable book of business over time
  • Serve as a senior market contact for retail brokers and carrier partners
  • Structure and maintain carrier capacity, governance, and reporting
  • Recruit, mentor, and develop underwriting talent as the business grows

Background

  • 12+ years' experience in specialty underwriting with clear leadership responsibility
  • Proven ownership of a meaningful specialty book or portfolio
  • Strong senior‑level broker and carrier relationships
  • Background within MGA, program, or smaller specialty carrier environments strongly preferred
  • Commercial, entrepreneurial mindset with interest in long‑term equity participation

Role Fit & Philosophy

This role is best suited to individuals who want to build as part of a broader platform, rather than operate independently with financial backing alone. Collaboration, shared ownership, and long‑term alignment are core to the model.

This is not a traditional underwriting role, but an opportunity to build and lead a specialty underwriting business within an entrepreneurial MGA structure.

Consumer‑focused or commoditized personal lines opportunities are not within scope.

FAQs

Congratulations, we understand that taking the time to apply is a big step. When you apply, your details go directly to the consultant who is sourcing talent. Due to demand, we may not get back to all applicants that have applied. However, we always keep your CV and details on file so when we see similar roles or see skillsets that drive growth in organisations, we will always reach out to discuss opportunities.

Yes. Even if this role isn’t a perfect match, applying allows us to understand your expertise and ambitions, ensuring you're on our radar for the right opportunity when it arises.

We also work in several ways, firstly we advertise our roles available on our site, however, often due to confidentiality we may not post all. We also work with clients who are more focused on skills and understanding what is required to future-proof their business. 

That's why we recommend registering your CV so you can be considered for roles that have yet to be created. 

Yes, we help with CV and interview preparation. From customised support on how to optimise your CV to interview preparation and compensation negotiations, we advocate for you throughout your next career move.

Handpicked roles for you