Back to blogs

Compensation Trends in the Insurance Industry

Posted on May 2023

Compensation trends

The insurance sector, much like every other industry, is in a constant state of evolution. Particularly, the compensation landscape within this sector has seen some transformative shifts in recent years. At Selby Jennings, we understand these changes are significantly impacting hiring practices and strategies. As a leading specialist in insurance and actuarial talent sourcing, we keep our finger on the pulse of these trends, ensuring we provide effective, data-driven talent acquisition solutions for our clients.

We have probed further into the evolving compensation trends within the insurance industry. We will navigate through the growing necessity for emerging skills, shed light on the pivotal role of diversity and inclusion in insurance, explore the trend towards more flexible compensation packages, and discuss how regulatory changes are shaping compensation strategies within the industry.

The Escalating Demand for Emerging Skills

In the face of digital transformation, insurance has seen a surge in demand for new skill sets. Skills such as data analytics, artificial intelligence, machine learning, and cyber risk management have become indispensable in today's insurance landscape. Professionals possessing these skills can leverage data to improve risk assessment, enhance customer experiences, and protect against cyber threats, thereby bringing immense value to insurance companies.

Due to the relatively scarce supply of these specialized skills in the market, professionals who possess them often command higher salaries. As a result, compensation packages for roles requiring such skills have seen a significant upward trend, making the insurance sector more competitive for these talents.

The Integral Role of ED&I

ED&I have moved from being mere buzzwords to integral components of organizational strategy when hiring. As insurance companies strive to create inclusive work environments, compensation strategies have been impacted as well.

To ensure fairness and transparency, companies are conducting pay equity audits and revising their compensation practices. These initiatives aim to eliminate any gender, racial, or ethnic wage gaps. Moreover, there's a growing trend towards compensating employees equitably for equivalent work, irrespective of their backgrounds.

Embracing Flexibility in Compensation Packages

The insurance industry's competitive hiring landscape has paved the way for remarkable transformations in compensation packages. Insurers now understand that monetary rewards alone are insufficient to attract and retain the best professionals. That's why they are embracing a more flexible approach, offering enticing non-monetary benefits alongside financial compensation.

In addition to monetary rewards, top insurers are increasingly incorporating non-monetary benefits like flexible work schedules, remote work options, comprehensive health benefits, and professional development opportunities. These enticing perks may not directly affect take-home pay, but they play a pivotal role in enhancing overall job satisfaction and work-life balance, making companies far more appealing to prospective employees.

To explore how these innovative compensation packages are revolutionizing the industry, it's essential to download the Selby Jennings Future of Flexible Working Report. Gain access to cutting-edge information, statistics, and best practices that will equip you with the knowledge needed to excel in attracting, retaining, and nurturing top talent.

Navigating Regulatory Changes

The insurance sector is heavily impacted by national and international affairs, causing constant regulatory changes which can be complicated, time-consuming and expensive to implement. For example, new regulations are often implemented in the wake of hurricanes, and The Affordable Care Act (ACA) had a profound impact on the entire US regulatory insurance sector.

As a result, hiring the right talent is vital to keep on top of the latest requirements and implement changes effectively, but the sector is experiencing intense competition for the best talent due to a lack of qualified candidates with the necessary expertise and experience. Insurance companies also need to be able to act upon developments as soon as they happen, so it is imperative that companies have the right talent already in place when changes occur.

By offering competitive salaries and compensation to attract and retain top talent, and partnering with a specialist talent agency like Selby Jennings with an existing global network of highly skilled professionals, companies can remain compliant with regulatory updates while keeping ahead of their competitors in the marketplace.

The Shift Towards Performance-Based Compensation

The insurance industry has been increasingly shifting towards performance-based compensation models. Bonuses, profit-sharing plans, and stock options tied to an employee's performance and the company's profitability are becoming more prevalent.

This trend, driven by the aim to incentivize high performance and align employee interests with company goals, has resulted in a more merit-based compensation system, encouraging employees to contribute to their fullest potential.

​As the insurance industry continues to evolve and adapt, it becomes increasingly crucial to have a knowledgeable and experienced partner guiding you through the complexities of talent acquisition. At Selby Jennings, we are that partner. Our deep-rooted understanding of the insurance industry, coupled with our proficiency in identifying emerging talent, positions us perfectly to provide you with unparalleled assistance.

We are at the forefront of the industry's growing demand for emerging skills, the shift towards flexible compensation packages, and the effects of regulatory changes. With these insights, we are well-equipped to help you identify, attract, and retain the industry's top talent.

Looking for exceptional talent? Request a call back from one of our specialized talent experts today.

We also highly recommend our latest report, "Insuring the Future". This comprehensive resource provides an in-depth examination of the latest strategies that are shaping the future of the insurance sector. Harness these insights to stay ahead in the rapidly evolving landscape of the insurance industry.

Download Report